Right to Work vs. Right to Compete
According to a story at Breitbart’s Big Government site, a Democrat Congressman named Brad Sherman is trying get a law passed that would eliminate right-to-work states, making every state a unionized state. The claim is that the unions in right-to-work states are, in effect, negotiating higher wages and benefits for cheaper, non-union workers who take a “free ride” on the efforts of the union, collecting better wages and benefits without paying for the representation. This would change the labor structure of 22 states overnight should he be successful.
The effect of this change would be catastrophic. Businesses would have to rethink their whole way of doing business. Prices would rise to cover the increased costs of doing business. I can only wonder what this would do to the poor, who are on welfare and without jobs. Would their welfare payments have to go up to cover the increased costs of food, energy, and other life essentials which would be handled by higher priced union labor? If their welfare checks go up to enable the recipients to pay for these increased prices, would that be another excuse to raise taxes? What would happen to the somewhat recession resistant job market that we in Texas have enjoyed for, lo, these many years?
The effect on politics would be even more striking. With unions being a de facto arm of the Democrat party, would people with a history of voting independently or even for Republicans tend to vote for Democrats under pressure from their union leaders? I had a friend whose husband is an electrician. We were discussing votes and she made the comment that they “had to vote Democrat”. According to her, she had to vote for the ones “who paid her husband so well”.
From the Breitbart story:
Although Congressman Sherman introduced this legislation back in 2008, it had little chance of succeeding. However, with the mid-term elections and a lame-duck Congress following, the chances that Democrats (who are taking hundreds of millions from unions), it is possible the chances that Democrats could vote to end Right-to-Work states.
As a result, now is as good a time as any to get Democrats (in both Right-to-Work states and forced-union states) to state their positions on whether they support an end to workers’ right to work.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.